Satisfying decisions and the limits of overthinking
Sometimes the decisions we are most satisfied with are the ones we genuinely commit to, even if we have not analysed them exhaustively.
This idea, developed by psychologist James Langabeer, challenges the belief that ‘the more I think about it, the less I will regret it’.
Why overthinking can increase regret
Langabeer explains that many people end up regretting most the decisions they agonised over longest. The outcome may have been reasonable, but deliberating for so long helps them imagine, in considerable detail, the paths they did not take. In psychology, regret depends both on what happened and how vividly we picture the alternatives we gave up. When we revisit a decision repeatedly, we give those other scenarios more weight and feed the feeling that we missed an opportunity. We become stuck thinking about what might have been, even if our choice made sense.
Overanalysis can also lead to paralysis. Fear of making a mistake leads us to put off the decision, increasing anxiety and the feeling that we are losing control of our lives.
Acceptance and commitment
Langabeer suggests that satisfaction depends more on accepting and committing to our choice than on finding the perfect option. This allows us to regard the matter as settled without constantly reopening the question.
When we commit, we spend our energy making the choice work and stop undermining it from within. Cognitive dissonance theory suggests that aligning what we think, feel and do reduces inner conflict and promotes peace of mind.
How to make healthier decisions
From this perspective, a good decision is one you can live with without constantly fighting yourself over it. Here are a few ways to approach it.
• Narrow down your options. Choosing from a small number of clear alternatives reduces the sense of loss over those you ruled out.
• Set a time limit for deliberation. Decide beforehand how long you will think about the issue so you do not dwell on it indefinitely.
• Accept that you cannot be completely certain. Aiming to feel comfortable enough with a decision can ease anxiety more than insisting on absolute certainty.
• Actively commit to what you have chosen. Once you decide, put your effort into making it work and give less attention to what might have happened otherwise.
In practice, this means moving from ‘Did I make the right choice?’ to ‘What can I do now to make this decision meaningful for me?’
> CLÍNICAS NG NEWS section
Medical centre authorised by the Government of Catalonia, registration no. E08945122
Plastic, reconstructive and aesthetic surgery
Aesthetic medicine
93 716 95 25
654 32 67 57
// About Dr Nélida Grande
Dr Grande graduated in Medicine and Surgery from the Autonomous University of Barcelona. She specialises in plastic surgery of the breasts, body and face, and in advanced aesthetic medicine treatments. Drawing on her extensive professional experience, she sees beauty as closely linked to health. Her approach is to treat the body so that the mind can find its balance.